M.L. Rio's If We Were Villains isn't your typical college drama. This dark academia novel plunges readers into the intoxicating and treacherous world of a prestigious conservatory for classical actors, where ambition, obsession, and Shakespeare collide in a deadly cocktail. The book isn't just a mystery; it's a character study, a theatrical exploration of morality, and a chilling examination of the blurred lines between performance and reality.
The story unfolds through the retrospective narrative of Oliver, a young man haunted by a tragedy that occurred years prior during his time at Dellecher Classical Conservatory. The narrative circles back to the intense relationships within the tightly knit group of acting students—a passionate, volatile, and intensely creative cohort. We're introduced to a cast of richly drawn characters, each with their own flaws, desires, and secrets, all revolving around the enigmatic and charismatic director, the enigmatic Mr. Hoffman. Their intense dedication to their craft often bleeds into their personal lives, creating a potent brew of ambition, jealousy, and romantic entanglement.
The Atmosphere of Suspense and Intrigue
Rio masterfully crafts an atmosphere thick with suspense. The language is evocative, mirroring the dramatic flair of the characters' chosen profession. The reader is drawn into the claustrophobic intimacy of their shared lives, the intensity of their rehearsals, and the weight of their unspoken resentments. The constant allusions to Shakespearean tragedy, woven seamlessly into the narrative, heighten the sense of foreboding, foreshadowing the impending doom. The pacing is deliberate, carefully building tension before plunging the reader into the heart of the mystery.
Unraveling the Mystery: Who is the Villain?
What is the central mystery of the book? This question lies at the heart of If We Were Villains. The novel is structured around the investigation into a murder, blurring the lines between what is real and what is performance. As the narrative progresses, we're presented with multiple perspectives, each with their own biases and hidden agendas, making it nearly impossible to discern the truth. The reader, much like Oliver, is left questioning the nature of reality itself. Are the characters playing roles, or are they simply enacting their true selves? This ambiguity is a key strength of the novel, leaving a lasting impact long after you finish reading.
What happens to the characters after the play? The aftermath of the play and the ensuing tragedy irrevocably alters the lives of the characters. The investigation and its implications fracture the group, revealing the dark undercurrents that simmered beneath the surface of their seemingly perfect world. The novel explores the lasting consequences of their actions and the psychological scars they bear.
What roles did the other characters play in the events? Each character, driven by their own ambitions and desires, contributes to the unfolding events. Their relationships, both romantic and platonic, are intensely complex and often fraught with jealousy, betrayal, and fierce competition. The novel slowly reveals the motivations and actions of each character, leading to surprising revelations and turning the reader's perceptions on their heads.
Is there a sequel to If We Were Villains? Currently, there is no sequel to If We Were Villains. While the novel's ending is conclusive, the lingering questions and the enduring power of its characters leave the reader yearning for more.
A Masterpiece of Dark Academia
If We Were Villains is more than just a mystery; it's a captivating exploration of art, ambition, and the dangerous consequences of unchecked passion. Rio's writing is both beautiful and unsettling, creating a narrative that stays with the reader long after the final page is turned. The characters are complex and compelling, and the mystery itself is both intricate and deeply satisfying. If you enjoy atmospheric thrillers with a touch of dark academia, this book is an absolute must-read.
